Article
GARY HANNA

The Evil Swirling Darkness

The incredible story of a family and a storm chaser caught in a tornado

By Lauren Tarshis
From the Issue

Learning Objective: Students will read a nonfiction story about the deadly tornado that struck Joplin, Missouri, in 2011. The story will build knowledge and domain-specific vocabulary, and has a special emphasis on sequencing.

Lexiles: Starter, 580L, 750L, 970L
Guided Reading Level: Q
DRA Level: 40
Think and Read: Sequencing

As you read, think about the order of events that involve Bennett, Ethan, and the rest of the Satterlee family.

It was Sunday, May 22, 2011. Before the day was over, much of the city of Joplin, Missouri, would be in ruins. One hundred fifty-eight people would be dead and more than one thousand injured.

But as the day began, Ethan and Bennett Satterlee were thinking about a birthday party. It was Bennett’s 11th birthday, and both he and 7-year-old Ethan were excited for an afternoon pool party at their grandparents’ house.

Meanwhile, 230 miles away in Norman, Oklahoma, storm chaser Jeff Piotrowski [puh-TROW-skee] was worried. For more than 35 years, Piotrowski had been studying thunderstorms and tornadoes.

Tornadoes are hard to spot. Once a tornado forms, it cannot be seen, even by the most powerful radar. It remains hidden until it roars out of the storm clouds to destroy everything in its path. Piotrowski had just been tracking a dangerous storm system. He knew it might create tornadoes later that day. But exactly when? And where?

The Satterlee family lives in Joplin, Missouri. On Sunday, May 22, 2011, Ethan and Bennett Satterlee were excited for a party. It was Bennett’s 11th birthday. They were going to have a pool party at their grandparents’ house. But then they heard that there might be a thunderstorm later that day.

It was Sunday, May 22, 2011. Soon, much of the city of Joplin, Missouri, would be destroyed. One hundred fifty-eight people would be dead. More than one thousand would be injured.

But at the beginning of the day, Ethan and Bennett Satterlee were excited for a party. It was Bennett’s 11th birthday. Both he and 7-year-old Ethan were excited for a pool party at their grandparents’ house.

At the same time, 230 miles away, storm chaser Jeff Piotrowski [puh-TROW-skee] was worried. Piotrowski had been studying storms for more than 35 years.

Tornadoes are hard to spot. Once a tornado forms, it cannot be seen. Not even by the most powerful radar. It remains hidden. Then it roars out of the clouds to wreck everything in its path. Piotrowski had just been tracking a big storm system. He knew it might create tornadoes later that day. But exactly when? And where?

It was Sunday, May 22, 2011. Before the day was over, much of the city of Joplin, Missouri, would be in ruins. One hundred fifty-eight people would be dead and more than one thousand more injured. But earlier that day, what Ethan and Bennett Satterlee were thinking about was a birthday party.

It was Bennett’s 11th birthday, and both boys were excited for an afternoon pool party at their grandparents’ house. That morning after church, their mom, Shannon, had baked Bennett’s favorite vanilla cake. 

Bennett and 7-year-old Ethan had taken heaping spoonfuls of leftover vanilla icing into the yard, where they had devoured the sticky leftovers with strawberries plucked from the family’s garden.

As the brothers laughed under the hazy blue sky, neither had any idea that their city would soon be hit by one of the deadliest tornadoes in United States history.

Meanwhile, 230 miles away in Norman, Oklahoma, storm chaser Jeff Piotrowski was worried. For more than 35 years, Piotrowski had been studying supercell thunderstorms. These are the violent storms that sometimes unleash tornadoes.

Over the past few days, Piotrowski had been tracking a large and dangerous storm system that had been making its way east toward Kansas and Missouri. He could see that conditions were shaping up for dangerous tornadoes later that Sunday afternoon.

But exactly when would they strike? And where?

The Storm Chaser

The Storm Chaser

The Storm Chaser

Tornado Mysteries

Meteorologists believed that a tornado was most likely going to strike in Kansas, near the Missouri border. By 11 a.m., Piotrowski was in his truck, hoping to catch up with the storm by late afternoon.

Storm chasers like Piotrowski try to unlock the secrets of tornadoes. These men and women often provide early warnings that tornadoes are coming. This helps save lives. Over the years, Piotrowski has seen more than 850 tornadoes hit.

But he could not have imagined the horror of what was to come later that afternoon in Joplin.

At the same time, storm chaser Jeff Piotrowski [puh-TROW-skee] was worried. He thought the thunderstorm could turn into a tornado. Storm chasers like Piotrowski try to learn about tornadoes. He drove toward Joplin to follow the storm.

Meteorologists thought that a tornado was probably going to hit Kansas, near the Missouri border. By 11 a.m., Piotrowski was in his truck. He was hoping to catch up with the storm.

Storm chasers like Piotrowski try to unlock the secrets of tornadoes. These men and women can often warn people that storms are coming. This helps save lives. Piotrowski has seen more than 850 tornadoes hit.

But he could not have imagined the horror of what was to come later that afternoon in Joplin.

Today, meteorologists can predict many kinds of weather with amazing accuracy. They can tell you a week in advance whether your Little League game could be rained out or if you’ll need snow boots for recess.

Tornadoes, however, remain stubbornly mysterious. They almost always form inside supercells. But only 20 percent of supercells produce tornadoes, and it’s difficult to know which storms will launch killer twisters and which will fizzle out.

And once a tornado has formed within the roiling clouds of a supercell, it cannot be seen, even by the most powerful radar. Like secretive monsters coming to life inside dark caves, tornadoes remain completely hidden until they roar out of the storm clouds to devour everything in their paths.

Piotrowski and other forecasters believed that a tornado was most likely going to strike in eastern Kansas, near the border with Missouri. By 11 a.m., he and his wife, Kathryn, were in their Chevy Avalanche truck, hoping to catch up with the storm by late afternoon.

Some storm chasers are looking mainly for thrills, speeding after violent weather, hoping to capture awesome videos to post on YouTube. But others, like Piotrowski, are working to unravel the secrets of tornadoes. These men and women often provide early warnings that tornadoes are coming, which helps save lives. Over the years, Piotrowski has witnessed more than 850 tornado strikes.

But he could not have imagined the horror of what was to come later that afternoon in Joplin.

The United States of Tornadoes

Tornadoes can and do strike anywhere on Earth (except Antarctica). But America is hit more than any other country, by far.

Every year, an average of more than 1,000 tornadoes touch down in the U.S. The biggest tornadoes tend to occur in an area known as Tornado Alley (see the orange section of the map). But tornadoes have been recorded in every state except Alaska.

False Alarms?

False Alarms

False Alarms?

False Alarms

LAGOW PORTRAIT DESIGNS INC.

A New Beginning

The Satterlee family, outside their rebuilt house (left to right): Bennett, now 16; Shannon; Barrett; Carolyn, now 8; and Ethan, now 12

The Satterlees heard that severe thunderstorms were predicted for later that day. That was disappointing. They’d have to move the party from their grandparents’ pool back to their house.

Weather forecasts said that tornadoes were possible, but tornado alerts are common in Joplin. And the city hadn’t been hit by a major tornado in nearly 40 years. All those false alarms had led most people to ignore the sirens that warn of tornadoes. In fact, Bennett and Ethan had gone to their grandparents’ house to swim. By 4:30 p.m., Bennett had returned home. Everyone waited for Ethan to come home with his cousin Wyatt, uncle Frank, and aunt Sana.

At 5:11, Joplin’s tornado sirens rang out. Bennett’s mom called Uncle Frank. “We’re getting close,” he promised.

Weather forecasts in Joplin said tornadoes were possible. Joplin had a lot of tornado warnings. Sirens rang to warn people. But the city hadn’t seen a big tornado in 40 years. That’s why many people ignored the sirens.

Bennett and Ethan went swimming at their grandparents’ house. Then Bennett went home. The family waited for Ethan to come home too. He would come with his cousin Wyatt, uncle Frank, and aunt Sana.

The tornado sirens rang. Bennett’s mom called Uncle Frank. “We’re getting close,” he said.

The Satterlees heard that strong thunderstorms might happen later that day. That was disappointing. They’d have to have the party inside.

Weather forecasts said that tornadoes were possible. But tornado alerts are common in Joplin. And the city hadn’t been hit by a big tornado in almost 40 years. All those false alarms had led people to ignore tornado warnings. Bennett and Ethan had even gone to swim in their grandparents’ pool. By 4:30 p.m., Bennett was home. Everyone waited for Ethan to come home with his cousin Wyatt, uncle Frank, and aunt Sana.

At 5:11, Joplin’s tornado sirens rang out. Bennett’s mom called Uncle Frank. “We’re getting close,” he said.

Like most people in Joplin, the Satterlees heard that severe thunderstorms were predicted for later that day. That was disappointing; they’d have to move the party from poolside back to their house. Weather forecasts said that tornadoes were possible, but this was not unusual. Tornado alerts are common in Joplin. The city has 28 tornado sirens, which sound frequently in the spring.

But as of that Sunday, the city hadn’t been hit by a major tornado in nearly four decades. Years of false alarms had led most people to ignore the sirens. Few in the city were concerned when Sunday’s weather forecast for Joplin worsened. Stores were packed with shoppers. Playgrounds rang with kids’ shrieks and laughs. Bennett and Ethan headed to their grandparents for a pre-party swim. By 4:30 p.m., Bennett had returned home, and his relatives were arriving for the party. Guests nibbled on chips and salsa as they waited for Ethan to return home with his cousin Wyatt, Uncle Frank, and Aunt Sana.

At 5:11, Joplin’s tornado sirens rang out. Looking out the window, the Satterlees saw nothing but pouring rain. Another false alarm, it seemed.

Still, Bennett’s mom sent the kids to the basement and turned on the TV to monitor weather reports. She called Uncle Frank on his cell phone. “We’re getting close,” he promised.

No False Alarm

The Storm Hits

No False Alarm

Impossible to See

THE WICHITA EAGLE/AP PHOTO

Chasing the Storm

Jeff Piotrowski speaks to 911 operators after spotting the tornado in Joplin.

Piotrowski arrived in Joplin just a few minutes later. He was sure that a tornado was about to strike. As he drove through the city, all seemed calm. But then he spotted a gigantic gray cloud moving in. It was an enormous tornado.

Piotrowski called 911. By then, weather forecasters throughout the region realized that Joplin was in serious danger. At 5:31, Joplin’s sirens sounded again. It was unusual for the sirens to sound a second time so quickly. Most people understood that this was no false alarm.

Piotrowski got to Joplin. He saw a huge gray cloud. It was a tornado. He called 911. The sirens rang again. People understood that this wasn’t a false alarm.

The Satterlees ran into their basement. It had concrete walls. They used it as a tornado shelter. The tornado hit. It destroyed everything in its path. The Satterlees could hear their house being torn apart. They didn’t know where Ethan, Wyatt, Frank, and Sana were.

Piotrowski got to Joplin a few minutes later. He was sure that a tornado was about to strike. As he drove through the city, it seemed calm. But then he spotted a huge gray cloud. It was a tornado.

Piotrowski called 911. By then, weather forecasters realized that Joplin was in serious danger. At 5:31, Joplin’s sirens rang again. It was unusual for the sirens to sound a second time so soon. Most people understood that this was no false alarm.

The Piotrowskis arrived in Joplin just a few minutes later. Studying storm data on the laptop in his truck, Piotrowski was convinced that a tornado was about to strike. As he drove through the city’s historic downtown, all seemed calm at first. But then he spotted a gigantic gray cloud moving in from the west. He soon realized what he was seeing: an enormous tornado.

And it was getting bigger by the second. 

What made this tornado especially dangerous was that it was “rain-wrapped,” or hidden behind a curtain of rain clouds.

Piotrowski called 911, alerting authorities that a dangerous tornado was rushing toward southern Joplin. He spotted a police officer sitting in a parked patrol car. Piotrowski stopped his truck and leaped out.

“That’s a dangerous tornado!” he shouted, pointing up at the approaching gray cloud. “Get the sirens going! Get the sirens going!”

By then, weather forecasters throughout the region realized that Joplin was in grave danger. At 5:31, Joplin’s sirens sounded again. It was extremely unusual for the sirens to sound twice in such a short period of time. Most people understood that this was no false alarm.

An Awful Attack


An Awful Attack

Vicious Attack

COURTESY OF THE SATTERLEE FAMILY

Broken Homes

Ethan’s parents watch as their damaged house is torn down.

The Satterlees and their guests ran into their basement storage room. It had concrete walls and they used it as their tornado shelter.

Outside, the tornado began attacking the city. Its 200-mile-per-hour winds destroyed brick buildings. It turned houses into piles of splintered wood and shattered glass. And it hurled cars and trucks thousands of feet.

From their basement shelter, the Satterlees and their guests could hear the heartbreaking sounds of their home being ripped apart. All they could think of was Ethan, Wyatt, Frank, and Sana. They were somewhere outside, caught in the evil swirling darkness.


The Satterlees and their guests ran into their basement storage room. It had concrete walls. They used it as their tornado shelter.

Outside, the tornado hit the city. Its 200-mile-per-hour winds wrecked brick buildings. It turned houses into piles of wood and broken glass. And it threw cars and trucks thousands of feet.

From their basement shelter, the Satterlees and their guests could hear their home being ripped apart. All they could think of was Ethan, Wyatt, Frank, and Sana. They were somewhere outside, caught in the evil swirling darkness.

All around the city, people rushed for shelter. The lucky ones headed to the safety of below-ground basements. Others crammed into closets or bathrooms away from windows and exterior walls. People sought safety in stores like Walmart and Home Depot. At fast-food restaurants, managers herded customers into walk-in refrigerators with strong metal walls. The Satterlees and their guests ran into their basement storage room, a concrete-walled space that doubled as their tornado shelter.

Outside, the tornado, still gaining strength, began its vicious attack on the city. The monstrous twister was now a staggering three quarters of a mile wide. Its 200-mile-per-hour winds pulverized brick buildings, turned houses into piles of splintered wood and shattered glass, and hurled cars and trucks thousands of feet. Walmart, Home Depot, and dozens of other stores and restaurants collapsed. Six schools, including Joplin High School, were destroyed.

From their basement shelter, the Satterlees and their guests could hear deafening crashes and thuds above them, the heartbreaking sounds of their home being ripped apart.

But it wasn’t the house they were thinking about. It was Ethan, Wyatt, Frank, and Sana. They were somewhere outside, caught in the evil swirling darkness.

The Greatest Gift

The Best Gift

The Greatest Gift

Healing a City

KEITH MYERS/KANSAS CITY STAR/MCT VIA GETTY IMAGES

The Joplin tornado destroyed more than 7,500 buildings, including these homes.

When the tornado had finally finished with Joplin, it left behind a trail of rubble 13 miles long. More than a thousand people were injured. The tornado, America’s deadliest in 60 years, killed 158 people.

But Uncle Frank’s truck finally appeared. Frank, Sana, Ethan, and Wyatt were all safe.

Ethan will likely never forget the awful moments when the tornado hit the truck. The window was smashed and glass sprayed over him. He feared he might never see his family again.

But when Bennett Satterlee looks back on his 11th birthday, he knows he received the greatest gift imaginable.

“My family survived the tornado,” he explains.

The tornado hurt more than a thousand people. It killed 158 people. It was America’s deadliest tornado in 60 years. The Satterlees came up to find their house wrecked. Uncle Frank’s truck finally appeared. Frank, Sana, Ethan, and Wyatt were all safe. Bennett Satterlee knew that he had gotten the best birthday gift ever. “My family survived the tornado,” he says.

When the tornado had finally left Joplin, it left behind a trail of rubble 13 miles long. More than a thousand people were hurt. The tornado was America’s deadliest in 60 years. It killed 158 people.

But Uncle Frank’s truck finally appeared. Frank, Sana, Ethan, and Wyatt were all safe.

Ethan will never forget the awful moments when the tornado hit the truck. The window was smashed and glass sprayed over him. He was afraid he might never see his family again.

But when Bennett Satterlee looks back on his 11th birthday, he knows he received the greatest gift imaginable.

“My family survived the tornado,” he says.

The Piotrowskis drove alongside the tornado, swerving to avoid flying debris, fallen telephone poles, and sizzling wires. They passed ruined buildings and smashed cars until they came upon a neighborhood that had been destroyed. What was once a street of tidy houses was now an endless sea of mangled ruins. They pulled over and were soon helping people who were trapped and injured.

Around this same time, the Satterlees emerged from the storage room to discover rain pouring through missing chunks of roof. Walls had collapsed. Furniture was smashed. Outside, neighbors’ houses were torn apart.

Frank’s truck was nowhere to be seen.

Minutes crept by. The family prayed for the safety of Uncle Frank, Aunt Sana, Ethan, and Wyatt. Ethan’s parents and other adults headed out into their neighborhood to search for people in need of help.

By then, the tornado had finally finished with Joplin, leaving behind a trail of rubble 13 miles long. More than a thousand people were injured. Neighbors helped neighbors, tearing through piles of wreckage with their bare hands to reach those who were trapped. Teenage boys turned their trucks into ambulances. Ethan’s parents assisted those in need, and so did the Piotrowskis.

“I knew we had witnessed one of the deadliest tornadoes in modern times,” Jeff says.

And it was. The tornado, America’s deadliest in 60 years, killed 158 people.

For the Satterlees, though, the day did not end in tragedy.

Uncle Frank’s truck finally appeared. The back window was shattered. The metal was dented and battered. But Frank, Sana, Ethan, and Wyatt were all safe.

Ethan knows that he will likely never forget the terrifying moments when the tornado gripped the truck, when the window was smashed and glass sprayed over him, when he feared he might never see his family again.

But four years later, sharing their stories from that day, the Satterlee boys do not dwell on their frightening memories or all that the family lost that day. They speak of the power of their faith, the strength of their community, and the generosity of the thousands of people from around the country who came to help heal their wounded city.

Looking back on his 11th birthday, Bennett knows he received the greatest gift imaginable.

“My family survived the tornado.”

video (1)
Slideshows (1)
Audio ()
Activities (6)
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (1)
video (1)
Slideshows (1)
Audio ()
Activities (6) Download All Quizzes and Activities
Quizzes (1)
Answer Key (1)
Can’t-Miss Teaching Extras
Behind-the-scenes video

To watch a behind-the-scenes video about this article from when it originally appeared in Storyworks, click here. Your students will love hearing from Lauren Tarshis about her process of researching and writing this article!

 

More on Joplin

Did you know that before Lauren wrote this article, she wrote a whole book about the Joplin tornado? It’s one of the most popular of her I Survived series. Check it out here!

The state of Joplin now

If your students are wondering what Joplin is like now, more than 5 years after the tornado, you can show them this video of Fire Chief Jim Furgerson giving a tour of Joplin in 2016.

Dancing tornadoes

The wife of Jeff Piotrowski, the storm chaser in the article, is also a storm chaser. Kat Piotrowski created this video of a May 2016 storm in Kansas. She set it to music to illustrate how the tornado appears to be dancing.

 

More About the Article

Content-Area Connections

Social studies: geography

Science: weather, environment

Key Skills

sequencing, text structures, text evidence, key details, inference, text features, domain-specific vocabulary, narrative writing, close reading

Step-by-Step Lesson Plan

1. PREPARING TO READ

Watch a Video/Preview Text Features (25 minutes)

•This story is accompanied by a Video Read-Aloud, in which author Lauren Tarshis narrates the article as gripping photos and footage help students visualize what’s happening. Consider showing the video as a “first read.”

• Have students open their magazines to pages 4-5 and look at the headline and subhead. Ask:  How does the subhead help you understand what the headline means?

• Point out the Pause and Think boxes, starting on page 6, which aim to check basic comprehension. Explain that these questions will help the students better understand the story. (Students will delve into higher-level work with the close-reading questions.)

• Direct students to the map on page 7. Explain that the larger area of the map is shown in the inset. Ask them if they’re familiar with the area shown.

 • Ask students to look at the photos on pages 8 and 9. Using the information in the captions, discuss how destructive the tornado was.

Introduce Academic Vocabulary (15 minutes)

• We have highlighted in bold the words having to do with weather and tornadoes and defined them at the bottom of the column in which they appear. Preview these words by projecting or distributing our vocabulary activity and completing it together as a class.

• Highlighted words: storm chaser, radar, meteorologists, forecasts, tornado shelter, rubble

Set a Purpose for Reading  (5 minutes)

•  Call on a volunteer to read the Think and Read box on page 4 for the class.

2. CLOSE READING

Reading and Unpacking the Text

•First read: Read the story as a class. At the end of each section, use the Pause and Think questions to quickly check comprehension.

• Second read: Distribute some or all of the close-reading questions and preview them together. After the class answers the questions, discuss the answers together. Then discuss the critical-thinking question.

Close-Reading Questions (30 minutes)

• In the first section, why are Ethan and Bennett excited? (key details) They are excited for Bennett’s birthday pool party at their grandparents’ house.

• According to the section “The Storm Chaser,” how do warnings from storm chasers help save lives? (inference) Storm chasers warn people that tornadoes are coming so that people can prepare or escape.

• “False Alarms?” says that most people ignored the tornado sirens. Why is that?  (inference) People ignored the tornado sirens because they had gone off many times and nothing happened.

 • What’s the first thing that happens in the section “An Awful Attack”? (sequencing) The Satterlees and their guests take shelter in their basement storage room.

• The last section is called “The Greatest Gift.” What is the gift? (key detail) The greatest gift Bennett got for his birthday is his family surviving the tornado.

Critical-Thinking Question (10 minutes)

• If tornadoes could be predicted better, what could the Satterlees have done differently that day? How would that have changed the outcome of the storm? (sequencing, cause and effect) They could have made a plan for how to stay safe. They could have made sure that they were all in the basement tornado shelter together before the storm hit. If the tornado had been predicted, people would have had more time to leave town or get to a shelter, and fewer people would have gotten injured and/or died.

3. SKILL BUILDING

• Call on a volunteer to read aloud the Think and Write box at the bottom of page 9.

• Have students work in pairs to underline details that they would include in their journal entries. Regroup as a class to discuss which ones are most important.

• Brainstorm the first event for the journal entry.

• Have students write their entries in class or as homework.

Differentiate and Customize
For Independent Readers

This article follows several different people throughout the storm. Have students read the article and make timelines of what Bennett and Ethan Satterlee and Jeff Piotrowski were doing as the storm progressed.

For Struggling Readers

Have students do a second read of the article, pausing at the end of each section to answer the Pause and Think question. Have them highlight the evidence they used to answer each question.

For Small Groups

Divide students into groups. Have them do a second read of the article, taking turns reading each section aloud. Have them do some or all of the close-reading questions together. 

For Advanced Readers

Have students do research to find an article about the Joplin tornado that was published soon after it happened in 2011. Ask them to find at least three new facts about the tornado and write a short essay about the new things they learned.

For On Level Readers

Imagine that you’re either Bennett or Ethan. Write a journal entry that lists the events of May 22, 2011. Use details from this story and include at least 7 events. 

Text-to-Speech